C&P Exam Prep Guide for Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (DC 8017)
YOUR EXAM BLUEPRINT
Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis
An ALS exam is a neurological exam documenting muscle weakness and wasting. ALS carries a minimum 100 percent rating; the exam records the affected functions, under 38 CFR 4.124a.
DBQ used for this condition
- PPublic formDBQ NEURO ALS Lou Gehrigs DiseaseOpen the public DBQ
What the examination is likely to focus on
Functional-impact topics to describe
- ALS is assigned a minimum 100 percent rating; the exam documents weakness, speech, swallowing, and breathing.
- Findings map to 38 CFR 4.124a (amyotrophic lateral sclerosis DC 8017).
Which form the examiner uses
For amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (DC 8017), the C&P examiner completes the following Disability Benefits Questionnaire (DBQ):
- DBQ NEURO ALS Lou Gehrigs Disease (public PDF on VA.gov)
DBQs are Department of Veterans Affairs Form 21-0960 series documents. Public DBQs are hosted on benefits.va.gov. A handful are examiner-only and are not posted publicly.
The DBQ topics for this condition
These are the parts of the DBQ form that apply to amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (DC 8017). Sections the form uses for other conditions are left out. Topics marked Only if this applies depend on your own history, such as surgery, a device, or a complication; open one if it applies to you. Section and question numbers are the ones printed on the VA form.
ALS (Lou Gehrig's Disease)
Section I Diagnosis Form page 1
- 1A. Does the Veteran now have or has he or she ever been diagnosed with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS)?
- 1B. If "Yes," provide only diagnoses that pertain to ALS:
- Diagnosis # 1 -
- Diagnosis # 2 -
- Diagnosis # 3 -
- 1C. If there are additional diagnoses that pertain to amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, list using above format:
Section II Medical History Form page 2
- 2A. Describe the history (including onset and course) of the Veteran's ALS (brief summary):
- 2B. Dominant hand
- Right
- Left
- Ambidextrous
Section III Conditions, Signs and Symptoms due to ALS Form page 2
Only if this applies: This manifestation is reported, documented or being evaluated as due to the selected neurologic disease.
- 3A. Does the Veteran report any muscle weakness in the upper and/or lower extremities attributable to ALS?
- (If "Yes," document under strength testing in neurologic exam section)
- 3B. Does the Veteran have any pharynx and/or larynx and/or swallowing conditions attributable to ALS?
Options printed on the form (28)
- (If "Yes," check all that apply)
- Constant inability to communicate by speech
- Speech not intelligible or individual is aphonic
- Paralysis of soft palate with swallowing difficulty (nasal regurgitation) and speech impairment
- Hoarseness
- Dysphagia (difficulty swallowing)
- Requiring daily medication to control dysphagia
- Documented history of esophageal stricture(s) attributable to ALS (see Note 1) (If checked indicate if recurrent or refractory) esophagogastroduodenoscopy (EGD). (Indicate date of study in the Remarks section.)
- Note 1: Findings must be documented by barium swallow, computerized tomography (CT), or Note 2: Recurrent esophageal stricture is defined as the inability to maintain target esophageal diameter beyond 4 weeks after the target diameter has been achieved. Refractory esophageal stricture is defined as the inability to achieve target esophageal diameter despite receiving no fewer than 5 dilatation sessions performed at 2-week intervals.
- Has the esophageal stricture(s) been recurrent or refractory? (see Note 2)
- Without daily symptoms
- Without requirement for daily medications
- Requiring dilatation (if checked indicate frequency and list most recent dates):
- No more than 2 times a year
- 3 or more times a year
- Was there dilatation utilizing steroids at least 1 time per year?
- Date of dilatation:
- Requiring esophageal stent placement
- Treatment with surgical correction
- Aspiration
- Note 3: "Undernutrition” means a deficiency resulting from insufficient intake of one or multiple essential nutrients, or the inability of the body to absorb, utilize, or retain such nutrients.
- Undernutrition is characterized by failure of the body to maintain normal organ functions and peripheral neuropathy, muscle wasting, weakness, abdominal distention, ascites, and Body
- Undernutrition (see Note 3)
- healthy tissues. Signs and symptoms may include: loss of subcutaneous tissue, edema,
- Substantial weight loss (see Note 4)
- Mass Index below normal range. individual's baseline weight sustained for three months with diminished quality of self-care or work tasks. "Baseline weight” means the clinically documented average weight for the two-year period preceding the onset of illness or, if relevant, the weight recorded at the Veteran's most recent discharge physical. If neither of these weights is available or currently relevant, then use ideal body weight as determined by either the Hamwi formula or Body Mass Index tables, whichever is most favorable to the Veteran.
- Treatment with a percutaneous esophago-gastrointestinal tube Note 4: “Substantial weight loss” means involuntary loss greater than 20 percent of an (PEG tube)
- Other, symptom(s) specify:
- 3C. Does the Veteran report any respiratory conditions attributable to ALS?
- (If "Yes," provide PFT results under "Diagnostic Testing" Section)
- 3D. Does the Veteran report signs and/or symptoms of sleep apnea or sleep apnea-like condition attributable to ALS?
Options printed on the form (7)
- Note: If signs and/or symptoms of sleep apnea or sleep apnea-like condition are due to ALS, these symptoms are due to weakness in the palatal, pharyngeal, laryngeal, and/or respiratory musculature. A sleep study is not indicated to report symptoms of sleep apnea or sleep apnea-like conditions that are attributable to ALS.
- (If "Yes," check all that apply)
- Persistent daytime hypersomnolence
- Requires use of breathing assistance device
- Chronic respiratory failure with carbon dioxide retention or cor pulmonale
- Requires tracheostomy
- Note: Complete or partial loss of sphincter control refers to the inability to retain or expel stool at an appropriate time and place.
- 3E. Does the Veteran have impairment of sphincter control attributable to ALS?
- If "Yes," indicate severity:
- History of loss of sphincter control, currently asymptomatic
- Complete loss of sphincter control
- Partial loss of sphincter control
- 3F. Does the Veteran report bowel incontinence to solids and/or liquids attributable to ALS?
- If "Yes," indicate frequency:
- Less than once every six months, which requires wearing a pad at least once every six months
- At least once every six months, which requires wearing a pad at least once every six months
- Two or more times per month, which requires wearing a pad two or more times per month
- Two or more times per week, which requires wearing a pad two or more times per week
- Two or more times per day, which requires changing a pad two or more times per day
- 3G. Does the Veteran have a physician-prescribed bowel program?
Options printed on the form (10)
- If "Yes," indicate responsiveness:
- Fully responsive
- Partially responsive
- Not responsive
- Indicate the bowel program requirements (Check all that apply)
- Special diet
- Medication If checked, are there prescribed medication(s) beyond laxative use?
- Digital stimulation
- SurgeryIf checked, provide the date of surgery or anticipated date of surgery:
- Other, please describe:
- 3H. Does the Veteran report gastrointestinal symptoms attributable to ALS?
Options printed on the form (14)
- If "Yes," check all that apply
- Change in stool frequency
- Change in stool form
- Altered stool passage (straining and/or urgency)
- Mucorrhea
- Abdominal bloating
- Subjective distention
- Constipation
- Other (specify):
- Abdominal pain related to defecation (if checked, indicate frequency during the previous 3 months)
- None
- At least once
- At least 3 days per month
- At least 1 day per week
- 3I. Does the Veteran report voiding dysfunction causing urine leakage attributable to ALS?
- (If "Yes," check all that apply)
- Does not require/does not use absorbent material
- Requires absorbent material that is changed less than 2 times per day
- Requires absorbent material that is changed 2 to 4 times per day
- Requires absorbent material that is changed more than 4 times per day
- 3J. Does the Veteran report voiding dysfunction causing signs and/or symptoms of urinary frequency attributable to ALS?
Options printed on the form (9)
- (If "Yes," check all that apply)
- Daytime voiding interval greater than 3 hours
- Nighttime awakening to void less than 2 times
- Daytime voiding interval between 2 and 3 hours
- Nighttime awakening to void 2 times
- Daytime voiding interval between 1 and 2 hours
- Nighttime awakening to void 3 to 4 times
- Daytime voiding interval less than 1 hour
- Nighttime awakening to void 5 or more times
- 3K. Does the Veteran have voiding dysfunction causing findings, or report signs and/or symptoms of obstructed voiding attributable to ALS?
Options printed on the form (10)
- (If "Yes," check all signs and symptoms that apply)
- Hesitancy(If checked, is hesitancy marked?)
- Slow or weak stream(If checked, is stream markedly slow or weak?)
- Decreased force of stream(If checked, is force of stream markedly decreased?)
- Stricture disease requiring dilatation 1 to 2 times per year
- Stricture disease requiring periodic dilatation every 2 to 3 months
- Recurrent urinary tract infections secondary to obstruction
- Uroflowmetry peak flow rate less than 10cc/sec
- Post void residuals greater than 150 cc
- Urinary retention requiring intermittent or continuous catheterization
- 3L. Does the Veteran have voiding dysfunction requiring the use of an appliance attributable to ALS?
- (If "Yes," describe appliance):
- 3M. Does the Veteran have a history of recurrent symptomatic urinary tract infections attributable to ALS?
Options printed on the form (12)
- (If "Yes," check all treatments that apply)
- No treatment
- Suppressive drug therapy
- Lasting 6 months or longer
- For less than 6 months
- Hospitalization(If checked, indicate frequency of hospitalization)
- 1 or 2 per year
- More than 2 per year
- Drainage by stent or nephrostomy tube
- Continuous intensive management required
- Other management/treatment not listed above (Description of management/treatment including dates of treatment):
- For all options checked above, list medications/management/treatments used for urinary tract infection and indicate dates for courses of treatment over the past 12 months:
- 3N. Does the Veteran report erectile dysfunction or female sexual arousal disorder (FSAD) attributable to ALS?
- Note: Female Sexual Arousal Disorder (FSAD) refers to the continual or recurrent physical inability of a woman to accomplish or maintain an ample lubrication- swelling reaction during sexual intercourse. Decreased blood flow to the genital area is believed to contribute to FSAD similar to the role of vascular disease in male erectile dysfunction. Other causes may include nerve and/or tissue damage.
- 3A. Does the Veteran report any muscle weakness in the upper and/or lower extremities attributable to ALS?
Section IV Neurologic Exam Form page 6
- 4A. Speech
- Normal (If speech is abnormal, describe):
- Abnormal
- 4B. Gait
- Normal (If gait is abnormal and the veteran has more than one medical condition contributing to the abnormal gait, identify the condition(s) and describe each condition's contribution to the abnormal gait):
- Abnormal
- (describe):
- 4C. Strength - Rate strength according to the following scale:
Options printed on the form (217)
- 0/5 No muscle movement
- 2/5 No movement against gravity
- 4/5 Less than normal strength
- 1/5 Visible muscle movement, but no joint movement
- 3/5 No movement against resistance
- 5/5 Normal strength
- All Normal
- Shoulder flexion:
- Right:
- 5/5
- 4/5
- 3/5
- 2/5
- 1/5
- 0/5
- Left:
- 5/5
- 4/5
- 3/5
- 2/5
- 1/5
- 0/5
- Shoulder abduction:
- Right:
- 5/5
- 4/5
- 3/5
- 2/5
- 1/5
- 0/5
- Left:
- 5/5
- 4/5
- 3/5
- 2/5
- 1/5
- 0/5
- Elbow Flexion:
- Right:
- 5/5
- 4/5
- 3/5
- 2/5
- 1/5
- 0/5
- Left:
- 5/5
- 4/5
- 3/5
- 2/5
- 1/5
- 0/5
- Elbow Extension:
- Right:
- 5/5
- 4/5
- 3/5
- 2/5
- 1/5
- 0/5
- Left:
- 5/5
- 4/5
- 3/5
- 2/5
- 1/5
- 0/5
- Wrist Flexion:
- Right:
- 5/5
- 4/5
- 3/5
- 2/5
- 1/5
- 0/5
- Left:
- 5/5
- 4/5
- 3/5
- 2/5
- 1/5
- 0/5
- Wrist Extension:
- Right:
- 5/5
- 4/5
- 3/5
- 2/5
- 1/5
- 0/5
- Left:
- 5/5
- 4/5
- 3/5
- 2/5
- 1/5
- 0/5
- Grip:
- Right:
- 5/5
- 4/5
- 3/5
- 2/5
- 1/5
- 0/5
- Left:
- 5/5
- 4/5
- 3/5
- 2/5
- 1/5
- 0/5
- Pinch: (thumb to index finger)
- Right:
- 5/5
- 4/5
- 3/5
- 2/5
- 1/5
- 0/5
- Left:
- 5/5
- 4/5
- 3/5
- 2/5
- 1/5
- 0/5
- Hip flexion:
- Right:
- 5/5
- 4/5
- 3/5
- 2/5
- 1/5
- 0/5
- Left:
- 5/5
- 4/5
- 3/5
- 2/5
- 1/5
- 0/5
- Hip abduction:
- Right:
- 5/5
- 4/5
- 3/5
- 2/5
- 1/5
- 0/5
- Left:
- 5/5
- 4/5
- 3/5
- 2/5
- 1/5
- 0/5
- Knee Flexion:
- Right:
- 5/5
- 4/5
- 3/5
- 2/5
- 1/5
- 0/5
- Left:
- 5/5
- 4/5
- 3/5
- 2/5
- 1/5
- 0/5
- Knee Extension:
- Right:
- 5/5
- 4/5
- 3/5
- 2/5
- 1/5
- 0/5
- Left:
- 5/5
- 4/5
- 3/5
- 2/5
- 1/5
- 0/5
- Ankle Plantar Flexion:
- Right:
- 5/5
- 4/5
- 3/5
- 2/5
- 1/5
- 0/5
- Left:
- 5/5
- 4/5
- 3/5
- 2/5
- 1/5
- 0/5
- Ankle Dorsiflexion:
- Right:
- 5/5
- 4/5
- 3/5
- 2/5
- 1/5
- 0/5
- Left:
- 5/5
- 4/5
- 3/5
- 2/5
- 1/5
- 0/5
- 4D. Deep tendon reflexes (DTRs) - Rate reflexes according to the following scale:
Options printed on the form (61)
- 0 Absent
- 1+ Decreased
- 2+ Normal
- 3+ Increased without clonus
- 4+ Increased with clonus
- All Normal
- Biceps:
- Right:
- 1+
- 2+
- 3+
- 4+
- Left:
- 1+
- 2+
- 3+
- 4+
- Triceps:
- Right:
- 1+
- 2+
- 3+
- 4+
- Left:
- 1+
- 2+
- 3+
- 4+
- Brachioradialis:
- Right:
- 1+
- 2+
- 3+
- 4+
- Left:
- 1+
- 2+
- 3+
- 4+
- Knee:
- Right:
- 1+
- 2+
- 3+
- 4+
- Left:
- 1+
- 2+
- 3+
- 4+
- Ankle:
- Right:
- 1+
- 2+
- 3+
- 4+
- Left:
- 1+
- 2+
- 3+
- 4+
- 4E. Does the Veteran have muscle atrophy attributable to ALS?
- (If muscle atrophy is present, indicate location):
- (When possible, provide difference measured in cm between normal and atrophied side, measured at maximum muscle bulk:
- cm.)
- 4F. Summary of muscle weakness in the upper and/or lower extremities attributable to ALS (check all that apply):
Options printed on the form (29)
- Right upper extremity muscle weakness:
- None
- Mild
- Moderate
- Severe
- Complete (no remaining function)
- With atrophy
- Left upper extremity muscle weakness:
- None
- Mild
- Moderate
- Severe
- Complete (no remaining function)
- With atrophy
- Right lower extremity muscle weakness:
- None
- Mild
- Moderate
- Severe
- Complete (no remaining function)
- With atrophy
- Left lower extremity muscle weakness:
- None
- Mild
- Moderate
- Severe
- Complete (no remaining function)
- With atrophy
- Note: If the Veteran has more than one medical condition contributing to the muscle weakness, identify the condition(s) and describe each condition's contribution to the muscle weakness:
Section V Other Pertinent Physical Findings, Complications, Conditions, Signs and/or Symptoms Form page 8
Only if this applies: Related additional physical findings, complications or scars are reported or documented.
- 5A. Does the Veteran have any other pertinent physical findings, complications, conditions, signs and/or symptoms related to any conditions listed in the diagnosis section?
- (If "Yes," describe (brief summary)):
- 5B. Does the Veteran have any scars (surgical or otherwise) related to any conditions or to the treatment of any conditions listed in the diagnosis section?
- If "Yes," also complete the appropriate dermatological questionnaire.
- 5C. Comments, if any:
Section VI Mental Health Manifestations due to ALS or its Treatment Form page 8
Only if this applies: Related mental-health/cognitive manifestations are reported or documented.
- 6A. Does the Veteran have depression, cognitive impairment or dementia, or any other mental disorder attributable to ALS and/or its treatment?
- (If "Yes," ALSO complete the Mental Disorders Disability Benefits Questionnaire (schedule with appropriate provider))
Section VII Housebound Form page 8
Only if this applies: The condition substantially confines the veteran to the home or immediate premises.
- 7A. Due to ALS, is the Veteran substantially confined to his or her dwelling and the immediate premises (or if institutionalized, to the ward or clinical areas)?
- (If "Yes," describe how often per day or week and under what circumstances the Veteran is able to leave the home or immediate premises):
Section VIII Aid and Attendance Form page 9
Only if this applies: The condition causes a need for help with personal care, feeding, toileting, safety or other listed daily activities.
Printed at the top of this section (1)
- Note: Responses in this section should only relate to impairments or limitations that are due to ALS.
- 8A. Is the Veteran able to dress or undress him or herself without assistance?
- 8B. Does the Veteran have sufficient upper extremity coordination and strength to be able to feed him or herself without assistance?
- 8C. Is the Veteran able to attend to the wants of nature (toileting) without assistance?
- 8D. Is the Veteran able to bathe him or herself without assistance?
- 8E. Is the Veteran able to keep him or herself ordinarily clean and presentable without assistance?
- 8F. Does the Veteran need frequent assistance for adjustment of any special prosthetic or orthopedic appliance(s)
- (If "Yes," describe):
- Note: For VA purposes, "bedridden" will be that condition which actually requires that the claimant remain in bed. The fact that claimant has voluntarily taken to bed
- or that a physician has prescribed rest in bed for the greater or lesser part of the day to promote convalescence or cure will not suffice.
- 8G. Is the Veteran bedridden?
- 8H. Does the Veteran require care and/or assistance on a regular basis due to his or her physical and/or mental disabilities in order to protect him or herself from the hazards and/or dangers incident to his or her daily environment?
- 8I. List any condition(s), in addition to the Veteran's ALS, that causes any of the above limitations:
Section IX NEED FOR HIGHER LEVEL (i.e., more skilled) AID & ATTENDANCE (A&A) Form page 9
Only if this applies: Skilled home care or a higher level of aid and attendance is relevant.
- 9A. Does the Veteran require a higher, more skilled level of A&A?
- Note: For VA purposes, this skilled, higher level care includes (but is not limited to) health-care services such as physical therapy, administration of injections, placement of indwelling catheters, changing of sterile dressings, and/or like functions which require professional health-care training or the regular supervision of a trained health-care professional to perform. In the absence of this higher level of care provided in the home, the Veteran would require hospitalization, nursing home care, or other residential institutional care.
Section X Assistive Devices Form page 10
Only if this applies: A device is used due to this condition.
- 10A. Does the Veteran use any assistive device(s) as a normal mode of locomotion, although occasional locomotion by other methods may be possible?
Options printed on the form (19)
- (If "Yes," identify assistive device(s) used (check all that apply and indicate frequency)):
- Wheelchair
- Frequency of use:
- occasional occasional occasional occasional occasional
- regular regular regular regular regular
- constant constant constant constant constant
- Brace(s)
- Frequency of use:
- Crutch(es)
- Frequency of use:
- Cane(s)
- Frequency of use:
- Walker
- Frequency of use:
- Other:
- Frequency of use:
- occasional
- regular
- constant
- 10B. If the Veteran uses any assistive devices, specify the condition and identify the assistive device used for each condition:
Section XI Remaining Effective Function of the Extremities Form page 10
Printed at the top of this section (2)
- Note: The intention of this section is to permit the examiner to quantify the level of remaining function; it is not intended to inquire whether the Veteran should undergo an amputation with fitting of a prosthesis. For example, if the functions of grasping (hand) or propulsion (foot) are as limited as if the Veteran had an amputation and prosthesis, the examiner should check "yes" and describe the diminished functioning. The question simply asks whether the functional loss is to the same degree as
- if there were an amputation of the affected limb.
- 11A. Due to the ALS condition, is there functional impairment of an extremity such that no effective function remains other than that which would be equally well served by an amputation with prosthesis? (Functions of the upper extremity include grasping, manipulation, etc., while functions for the lower extremity include balance and propulsion, etc.)
- Yes, functioning is so diminished that amputation with prothesis would equally serve the Veteran
- 11B. If "Yes," indicate extremity(ies) (Check all extremities for which this applies)
- Right upper
- Left upper
- Right lower
- Left lower (For each checked extremity, describe loss of effective function, identify the condition causing loss of function, and provide specific examples) (brief summary):
Section XII Financial Responsibility Form page 11
- 12A. In your judgment, is the Veteran able to manage his or her benefit payments in his or her own best interest, or able to direct someone else to do so?
- (If "No," provide rationale):
Section XIII Diagnostic Testing Form page 11
Printed at the top of this section (1)
- Note - If pulmonary function testing (PFT) is indicated due to respiratory disability, and results are in the medical record and reflect the Veteran's current respiratory function, repeat testing is not required. DLCO and bronchodilator testing is not indicated for a restrictive respiratory disability such as that caused by muscle weakness due to ALS.
- 13A. Have PFTs been performed?
Options printed on the form (9)
- (If "Yes," provide most recent results, if available):
- FEV-1:
- % predicted
- Date of test:
- FVC:
- % predicted
- Date of test:
- FEV-1/FVC:
- Date of test:
- 13B. If PFTs have been performed, is the flow-volume loop compatible with upper airway obstruction?
- 13C. Are there any other significant diagnostic test findings and/or results?
- (If "Yes," provide type of test or procedure, date and results (brief summary)):
Section XIV Functional Impact Form page 11
- 14A. Does the Veteran's ALS impact his or her ability to work?
- (If "Yes," describe the impact of the Veteran's ALS, providing one or more examples)
Section XV Remarks Form page 12
Only if this applies: Additional relevant explanation, testing context or examination limitations need to be recorded.
- 15A. Remarks (if any - please identify the section to which the remark pertains when appropriate).
1 other section of this form covers other conditions, the examiner's signature, or answers you gave above, and is not part of this prep view. The examiner still works from the whole form.
This is a preparation view built from the current public VA forms. It is not an official VA crosswalk, it does not decide which exam VA orders, and it does not tell the examiner to skip anything. Measurements, diagnoses and opinions on the form are the examiner's to record.
What to expect at your C&P exam
An ALS exam is a neurological exam documenting muscle weakness and wasting. ALS carries a minimum 100 percent rating; the exam records the affected functions, under 38 CFR 4.124a.
1Initial interview (history)
- Weakness, muscle wasting, cramps, or twitching, and where it started.
- Changes in speech, swallowing, or breathing.
- Effect on walking, self-care, and daily activities.
- Current treatment and assistive devices.
2Physical examination
- A neurological exam: muscle strength, wasting (atrophy), reflexes, speech, swallowing, and breathing.
3Diagnostic tests the examiner may rely on
Used to confirm the diagnosis.
4Functional assessment
- ALS is assigned a minimum 100 percent rating; the exam documents weakness, speech, swallowing, and breathing.
- Findings map to 38 CFR 4.124a (amyotrophic lateral sclerosis DC 8017).
Test explainers open MedlinePlus (NIH National Library of Medicine), or Wikipedia where MedlinePlus has no matching page. This describes what happens and what is measured, not how to influence a result.
Rating Levels for DC 8017
The following tiers are reproduced from 38 CFR Part 4, the VA Schedule for Rating Disabilities. Toggle between the official VA criteria and a Plain English explanation.
Plain-English summaries are AI-generated to explain the official criteria. The official 38 CFR language is the binding legal standard. When in doubt, ask a VSO.
Evidence cited in published BVA decisions for DC 8017
Each row counts the issues for this diagnostic code that the Board granted or denied and whose decision text discussed that type of evidence. An issue is one condition the Board ruled on, and one decision can contain several. Remanded issues are not included. This is a count from the public record, not a prediction or a recommendation for any claim.
- Service treatment records: discussed in 118 granted or denied BVA issues (41 granted; 77 denied)
- Medical literature: discussed in 50 granted or denied BVA issues (40 granted; 10 denied)
- Buddy / lay statements: discussed in 93 granted or denied BVA issues (33 granted; 60 denied)
When the Board found the exam inadequate (DC 8017)
In 21 published Board of Veterans' Appeals decisions involving this condition, the Board found a C&P examination or medical opinion inadequate. Where the defect could be read from the decision, it was most often one of the following (counts are a floor from the decisions on file, not a total):
- 10 Failed to address a contention or part of the condition
- 8 Conclusion given without a supporting rationale
An inadequate exam is usually sent back for a new one rather than decided against the veteran. This is a factual report of published decisions, not advice about any exam or claim; whether an exam is adequate is decided case by case.
Disclaimer: This page reproduces public Department of Veterans Affairs forms (DBQs) and verbatim text from 38 CFR Part 4 (the VA Schedule for Rating Disabilities). It is informational only and is not legal or medical advice. For guidance on a specific claim, contact a VA-accredited representative.