C&P Exam Prep Guide for Thigh, limitation of flexion of (DC 5252)
YOUR EXAM BLUEPRINT
Thigh, limitation of flexion of
A hip exam is a hands-on physical exam. The examiner measures how the hip moves, tests it, and reviews imaging, then rates under 38 CFR 4.71a.
DBQ used for this condition
- PPublic formDBQ MUSC Hip and ThighOpen the public DBQ
What the examination is likely to focus on
Functional-impact topics to describe
- How much the hip motion is limited and whether you need an assistive device, which set the rating.
- Findings map to the tiers in 38 CFR 4.71a (hip and thigh DCs 5250-5255).
Which form the examiner uses
For thigh, limitation of flexion of (DC 5252), the C&P examiner completes the following Disability Benefits Questionnaire (DBQ):
- DBQ MUSC Hip and Thigh (public PDF on VA.gov)
DBQs are Department of Veterans Affairs Form 21-0960 series documents. Public DBQs are hosted on benefits.va.gov. A handful are examiner-only and are not posted publicly.
The DBQ topics for this condition
These are the parts of the DBQ form that apply to thigh, limitation of flexion of (DC 5252). Sections the form uses for other conditions are left out. Topics marked Only if this applies depend on your own history, such as surgery, a device, or a complication; open one if it applies to you. Section and question numbers are the ones printed on the VA form.
Hip and Thigh
Section I Diagnosis Form page 1
Printed at the top of this section (1)
- Note: These are condition(s) for which an evaluation has been requested on the exam request form (Internal VA) or for which the Veteran has requested medical evidence be provided for submission to VA.
- 1A. List the claimed conditions that pertain to this questionnaire:
- Note: These are the diagnoses determined during this current evaluation of the claimed condition(s) listed above. If there is no diagnosis, if the diagnosis is different from a previous diagnosis for this condition, or if there is a diagnosis of a complication due to the claimed condition, explain your findings and reasons in the remarks section. Date of diagnosis can be the date of the evaluation if the clinician is making the initial diagnosis or an approximate date determined through record review or reported history.
- 1B. Select diagnoses associated with the claimed condition(s) (check all that apply):
Options printed on the form (209)
- The Veteran does not have a current diagnosis associated with any claimed conditions listed above. (Explain your findings and reasons in the remarks section)
- Side affected:
- Osteoarthritis, hip
- Right
- Left
- Both
- Right:
- Left:
- Hip joint replacement
- Right
- Left
- Both
- Right:
- Left:
- Hip joint resurfacing
- Right
- Left
- Both
- Right:
- Left:
- Trochanteric pain syndrome (includes trochanteric bursitis)
- Right
- Left
- Both
- Right:
- Left:
- Femoral acetabular impingement syndrome (includes labral tears)
- Right
- Left
- Both
- Right:
- Left:
- Iliopsoas tendinitis
- Right
- Left
- Both
- Right:
- Left:
- Femoral neck stress fracture
- Right
- Left
- Both
- Right:
- Left:
- Avascular necrosis, hip
- Right
- Left
- Both
- Right:
- Left:
- Ankylosis of hip joint
- Right
- Left
- Both
- Right:
- Left:
- Degenerative arthritis, other than posttraumatic
- Right
- Left
- Both
- Right:
- Left:
- Arthritis, gonorrheal
- Right
- Left
- Both
- Right:
- Left:
- Arthritis, pneumococcic
- Right
- Left
- Both
- Right:
- Left:
- Arthritis, streptococcic
- Right
- Left
- Both
- Right:
- Left:
- Arthritis, syphilitic
- Right
- Left
- Both
- Right:
- Left:
- Arthritis, rheumatoid (multi-joints)
- Right
- Left
- Both
- Right:
- Left:
- Post-traumatic arthritis
- Right
- Left
- Both
- Right:
- Left:
- Arthritis, typhoid
- Right
- Left
- Both
- Right:
- Left:
- Other specified forms of arthropathy (excluding gout) (specify)
- Right
- Left
- Both
- Right:
- Left:
- Osteoporosis, residuals of Osteomalacia, residuals of Bones, neoplasm, benign
- Right
- Left
- Both
- Right:
- Left:
- Right
- Left
- Both
- Right:
- Left:
- Right
- Left
- Both
- Right:
- Left:
- Osteitis deformans
- Right
- Left
- Both
- Right:
- Left:
- Gout
- Right
- Left
- Both
- Right:
- Left:
- Bursitis
- Right
- Left
- Both
- Right:
- Left:
- Myositis
- Right
- Left
- Both
- Right:
- Left:
- Heterotopic ossification
- Right
- Left
- Both
- Right:
- Left:
- Tendinopathy (select one if known)
- Right
- Left
- Both
- Right:
- Left:
- Tendinitis
- Right
- Left
- Both
- Right:
- Left:
- Tendinosis
- Right
- Left
- Both
- Right:
- Left:
- Tenosynovitis
- Right
- Left
- Both
- Right:
- Left:
- Inflammatory other types (specify)
- Right
- Left
- Both
- Right:
- Left:
- Other (specify)
- Other diagnosis #1
- Side affected:
- Right
- Left
- Both
- Right:
- Left:
- Other diagnosis #2
- Side affected:
- Right
- Left
- Both
- Right:
- Left:
- Other diagnosis #3
- Side affected:
- Right
- Left
- Both
- Right:
- Left
- If there are additional diagnoses that pertain to hip and thigh conditions, list using above format:
Section II Medical History Form page 3
- 2A. Describe the history (including onset and course) of the Veteran's hip or thigh condition (brief summary):
- 2B. Does the Veteran report flare-ups of the hip or thigh?
- If yes, document the Veteran's description of the flare-ups he/she experiences, including the frequency, duration, characteristics, precipitating and alleviating factors, severity and/or extent of functional impairment he or she experiences during a flare-up of symptoms.
- 2C. Does the Veteran report having any functional loss or functional impairment of the joint or extremity being evaluated on this questionnaire, including but not limited to after repeated use over time?
- If yes, document the Veteran's description of functional loss or functional impairment in his/her own words.
Section III Range of Motion (rom) and Functional Limitation Form page 4
Printed at the top of this section (5)
- There are several separate parameters requested for describing function of a joint. The question "Does this ROM contribute to a functional loss?" asks if there is a functional loss that can be ascribed to any documented loss of range of motion; and, unlike later questions, does not take into account the numerous other factors to be considered. Subsequent questions take into account additional factors such as pain, fatigue, weakness, lack of endurance, or incoordination. If there is pain noted on examination, it is important to understand whether or not that pain itself contributes to functional loss. Ideally, a claimant would be seen immediately after repetitive use over time or during a flare-up; however, this is not always feasible.
- Information regarding joint function on repetitive use is broken up into two subsets. The first subset is based on observed repetitive use, and the second is based on functional loss associated with repeated use over time. The observed repetitive use section initially asks for objective findings after three or more repetitions of range of motion testing. The second subset provides a more global picture of functional loss associated with repetitive use over time. The latter takes into account medical probability of additional functional loss as a global view. This takes into account not only the objective findings noted on the examination, but also the subjective history provided by the claimant, as well as review of the available medical evidence.
- Optimally, a description of any additional loss of function should be provided - such as what the degrees of range of motion would be opined to look like after repetitive use over time. However, when this is not feasible, an "as clear as possible" description of that loss should be provided. This same information (minus the three repetitions) is asked to be provided with regards to flare-ups.
- Right hip
- Left hip
- 3A. Initial ROM measurements
Options printed on the form (72)
- All normal
- Abnormal or outside of normal range
- Unable to test
- Not indicated
- If "Unable to test" or "Not indicated" please explain:
- If ROM is outside of "normal" range, but is normal for the Veteran (for reason other than a hip/thigh condition, such as age, body habitus, neurologic disease), please describe:
- If abnormal, does the range of motion itself contribute to a functional loss? (if yes, please explain)
- Note: For any joint condition, examiners should address pain on both passive and active motion, and on both weight-bearing and nonweight-bearing. Examiners should also test the contralateral joint (unless medically contraindicated). If testing cannot be performed or is medically contraindicated (such as it may cause the Veteran severe pain or the risk of further injury), an explanation must be given below. Please note any characteristics of pain observed on examination (such as facial expression or wincing on pressure or manipulation).
- Can testing be performed?
- If no, provide an explanation:
- If this is the unclaimed joint, is it:
- Damaged
- Undamaged
- If undamaged, range of motion testing must be conducted.
- Active Range of Motion (ROM) - Perform active range of motion and provide the ROM values.
- Flexion endpoint (125 degrees)
- degrees degrees degrees degrees degrees degrees
- Extension endpoint (30 degrees)
- Abduction endpoint (45 degrees)
- Adduction endpoint (25 degrees)
- External rotation endpoint (60 degrees)
- Internal rotation endpoint (40 degrees)
- If noted on examination, which ROM exhibited pain (select all that apply):
- Flexion
- Abduction
- External Rotation
- Extension
- Adduction
- Internal Rotation degree
- If any limitation of motion is specifically attributable to pain, weakness, fatigability, incoordination, or other; please note the degree(s) in which limitation of motion is specifically attributable to the factors identified and describe.
- Flexion degree endpoint (if different than above)
- Extension degree endpoint (if different than above)
- Abduction degree endpoint (if different than above)
- Adduction degree endpoint (if different than above)
- External Rotation degree endpoint (if different than above)
- Internal Rotation degree endpoint (if different than above)
- Does a limitation in adduction prevent the Veteran from crossing his/her legs?
- Passive Range of Motion - Perform passive range of motion and provide the ROM values.
- Flexion endpoint (125 degrees)
- Same as active ROM degree
- Extension endpoint (30 degrees)
- Same as active ROM degree
- Abduction endpoint (45 degrees)
- Same as active ROM degree
- Adduction endpoint (25 degrees)
- Same as active ROM degree
- External rotation endpoint (60 degrees)
- Same as active ROM degree
- Internal rotation endpoint (40 degrees)
- Same as active ROM
- If noted on examination, which ROM exhibited pain (select all that apply):
- Flexion
- Abduction
- External Rotation
- Extension
- Adduction
- Internal Rotation
- If any limitation of motion is specifically attributable to pain, weakness, fatigability, incoordination, or other; please note the degree(s) in which limitation of motion is specifically attributable to the factors identified and describe.
- Flexion degree endpoint (if different than above)
- Extension degree endpoint (if different than above)
- Abduction degree endpoint (if different than above)
- Adduction degree endpoint (if different than above)
- External Rotation degree endpoint (if different than above)
- Internal Rotation degree endpoint (if different than above)
- Does a limitation in passive adduction prevent the Veteran from crossing his/her legs?
- Is there evidence of pain?
- If yes check all that apply. weight-bearing active motion on rest/non-movement causes functional loss (if checked describe in the comments box below) does not result in/cause functional loss
- nonweight-bearing passive motion
- Comments:
- Is there objective evidence of crepitus?
- Is there objective evidence of localized tenderness or pain on palpation of the joint or associated soft tissue?
- If yes, please explain. Include location, severity, and relationship to condition(s).
- 3B. Observed repetitive use ROM
Options printed on the form (20)
- Is the Veteran able to perform repetitive-use testing with at least three repetitions?
- If no, please explain:
- Is there additional loss of function or range of motion after three repetitions?
- If yes, please respond to the following after the completion of the three repetitions:
- Flexion endpoint (125 degrees)
- degrees degrees degrees degrees degrees degrees
- Extension endpoint (30 degrees)
- Abduction endpoint (45 degrees)
- Adduction endpoint (25 degrees)
- External rotation endpoint (60 degrees)
- Internal rotation endpoint (40 degrees)
- Does limitation in adduction after observed repetitive use prevent the Veteran from crossing his/her legs?
- Select factors that cause this functional loss: (check all that apply)
- Pain
- Fatigability
- Weakness
- Lack of endurance
- Incoordination
- Other
- Note: When pain is associated with movement, the examiner must give a statement on whether pain could significantly limit functional ability during flare-ups and/or after repeated use over time in terms of additional loss of range of motion. In the exam report, the examiner is requested to provide an estimate of decreased range of motion (in degrees) that reflect frequency, duration, and during flare-ups - even if not directly observed during a flare-up and/or after repeated use over time.
- 3C. Repeated use over time
Options printed on the form (20)
- Is the Veteran being examined immediately after repeated use over time?
- Does procured evidence (statements from the Veteran) suggest pain, fatigability, weakness, lack of endurance, or incoordination which significantly limits functional ability with repeated use over time?
- Select factors that cause this functional loss: (check all that apply)
- Pain
- Fatigability
- Weakness
- Lack of endurance degrees degrees degrees degrees degrees degrees
- Incoordination
- Other
- Estimate range of motion in degrees for this joint immediately after repeated use over time based on information procured from relevant sources including the lay statements of the Veteran.
- Flexion endpoint (125 degrees)
- Extension endpoint (30 degrees)
- Abduction endpoint (45 degrees)
- Adduction endpoint (25 degrees)
- External rotation endpoint (60 degrees)
- Internal rotation endpoint (40 degrees)
- The examiner should provide the estimated range of motion based on a review of The examiner should provide the estimated range of motion based on a review of all procurable information - to include the Veteran's statement on examination, case-specific evidence (to include medical treatment records when applicable
- and lay evidence), and the examiner's medical expertise. If, after evaluation of the procurable and assembled data, the examiner determines that it is not feasible to provide this estimate, the examiner should explain why an estimate cannot be provided. The explanation should not be based on an examiner's shortcomings or a general aversion to offering an estimate on issues not directly observed.
- Please cite and discuss evidence. (Must be specific to the case and based on all procurable evidence.)
- Does limitation in adduction after repeated use over time prevent the Veteran from crossing his/her legs?
- 3D. Flare-ups
Options printed on the form (20)
- Is the examination being conducted during a flare-up?
- Does procured evidence (statements from the Veteran) suggest pain, fatigability, weakness, lack of endurance, or incoordination which significantly limits functional ability with flare-ups?
- Select factors that cause this functional loss: (check all that apply)
- Pain
- Fatigability
- Weakness
- Lack of endurance degrees degrees degrees degrees degrees degrees
- Incoordination
- Other
- Estimate range of motion in degrees for this joint during flare-ups based on information procured from relevant sources including the lay statements of the Veteran.
- Flexion endpoint (125 degrees)
- Extension endpoint (30 degrees)
- Abduction endpoint (45 degrees)
- Adduction endpoint (25 degrees)
- External rotation endpoint (60 degrees)
- Internal rotation endpoint (40 degrees)
- The examiner should provide the estimated range of motion based on a review of The examiner should provide the estimated range of motion based on a review of all procurable information - to include the Veteran's statement on examination, case-specific evidence (to include medical treatment records when applicable
- and lay evidence), and the examiner's medical expertise. If, after evaluation of the procurable and assembled data, the examiner determines that it is not feasible to provide this estimate, the examiner should explain why an estimate cannot be provided. The explanation should not be based on an examiner's shortcomings or a general aversion to offering an estimate on issues not directly observed.
- Please cite and discuss evidence. (Must be specific to the case and based on all procurable evidence.)
- Does limitation in adduction during flare-ups prevent the Veteran from crossing his/her legs?
- 3E. Additional factors contributing to disability
Options printed on the form (14)
- In addition to those addressed above, are there additional contributing factors of disability? Please select all that apply and describe:
- None
- Interference with sitting
- Interference with standing
- Swelling
- Disturbance of locomotion
- Deformity
- Less movement than normal
- More movement than normal
- Weakened movement
- Atrophy of disuse
- Instability of station
- Other, describe:
- Please describe additional contributing factors of disability:
Section IV Muscle Atrophy Form page 9
Printed at the top of this section (2)
- RIGHT HIP
- LEFT HIP
- 4A. Does the Veteran have muscle atrophy?
- 4B. If yes, is the muscle atrophy due to the claimed condition in the diagnosis section?
- If no, provide rationale:
- 4C. For any muscle atrophy due to a diagnosis listed in Section I, indicate specific location of atrophy, providing measurements in centimeters of normal side and corresponding atrophied side, measured at maximum muscle bulk.
- Right lower extremity (specify location of measurement such as "10cm above or below the hip"):
- Left lower extremity (specify location of measurement such as "10cm above
- or below the hip"):
- Circumference of more normal side:
- cm cm
- Circumference of atrophied side:
Section V Ankylosis Form page 9
Printed at the top of this section (3)
- RIGHT HIP
- LEFT HIP
- Note: Ankylosis is the immobilization of a joint due to disease, injury, or surgical procedure.
- 5A. Is there ankylosis of the hip and/or thigh?
- If yes, indicate the severity of ankylosis:
- Unfavorable, extremely unfavorable ankylosis, foot not reaching ground, crutches needed
- Intermediate, between favorable and unfavorable
- Favorable, in flexion at an angle between 20 and 40 degrees, and slight abduction or adduction
Section VI Femur or Flail Hip Joint Impairment Form page 10
Only if this applies: Femoral malunion/nonunion, a flail hip or leg-length discrepancy is present.
Printed at the top of this section (3)
- RIGHT HIP
- LEFT HIP
- Note: If impairment of the femur causes an associated knee disability, please complete the additional appropriate questionnaire.
- 6A. Does the Veteran have malunion or non union of femur, flail hip joint or leg length discrepancy?
Options printed on the form (12)
- Fracture of shaft or neck (anatomical), with nonunion with loose motion (spiral or oblique fracture)
- Fracture of shaft or neck (anatomical), resulting in nonunion without loose motion; weight-bearing preserved with aid of brace
- Fracture of surgical neck with false joint
- Malunion of the femur
- Flail hip joint
- Leg length discrepancy (shortening of any bones of the lower extremity) (If checked, provide length of each lower extremity in inches (to the nearest 1/4 inch) or centimeters measuring from the anterior superior iliac spine to the internal malleolus of the tibia.)
- Measurements:
- Right leg:
- cm
- inch
- Left leg:
- For any leg length discrepancy, please describe the relationship to the conditions listed in the diagnosis section above:
Section VII Surgical Procedures Form page 10
Only if this applies: History of an operation or procedure for the selected condition, including replacement, resurfacing, repair or removal.
Printed at the top of this section (2)
- RIGHT HIP
- LEFT HIP
- 7A. Indicate any surgical procedures that the Veteran has had performed and provide the additional information as requested (check all that apply):
Options printed on the form (18)
- No surgery
- Hip joint resurfacing
- Date of surgery:
- Total hip joint replacement
- Date of surgery:
- Total hip joint replacement residuals:
- None
- Moderately severe residuals of weakness, pain or limitation of motion
- Markedly severe residuals of weakness, pain or limitation of motion following implantation of prosthesis
- Following implantation of prosthesis with painful motion or weakness such as to require the use of crutches
- Other, describe:
- Arthroscopic ligament repair
- Date of surgery:
- Other surgery not described (specify below):
- Date of surgery:
- Type of surgery:
- Residuals of arthroscopic or other hip surgery
- Describe residuals:
Section VIII Other Pertinent Physical Findings, Complications, Conditions, Signs, Symptoms, and Scars Form page 11
Only if this applies: A related complication, additional physical finding or scar is reported or documented.
- 8A. Does the Veteran have any other pertinent physical findings, complications, conditions, signs or symptoms related to any conditions listed in the diagnosis section above?
- If yes, describe (brief summary)
- 8B. Does the Veteran have any scars or other disfigurement (of the skin) related to any conditions or to the treatment of any conditions listed in the diagnosis section above?
- If yes, also complete the appropriate dermatological questionnaire.
Section IX Assistive Devices Form page 11
Only if this applies: A device is used because of this condition.
- 9A. Does the Veteran use any assistive devices as a normal mode of locomotion, although occasional locomotion by other methods may be possible?
Options printed on the form (31)
- If yes, identify the assistive devices used (check all that apply and indicate frequency):
- Wheelchair
- Frequency of use:
- Occasional
- Regular
- Constant
- Brace for ambulation
- Frequency of use:
- Occasional
- Regular
- Constant
- Crutches
- Frequency of use:
- Occasional
- Regular
- Constant
- Cane(s)
- Frequency of use:
- Occasional
- Regular
- Constant
- Walker
- Frequency of use:
- Occasional
- Regular
- Constant
- Other, describe:
- Frequency of use:
- Occasional
- Regular
- Constant
- 9B. If the Veteran uses any assistive devices, specify the condition, indicate the side, and identify the assistive device used for each condition.
Section X Remaining Effective Function of the Extremities Form page 12
Printed at the top of this section (2)
- Note: The intention of this section is to permit the examiner to quantify the level of remaining function; it is not intended to inquire whether the Veteran should undergo an amputation with fitting of a prosthesis. For example, if the functions of grasping (hand) or propulsion (foot) are as limited as if the Veteran had an amputation and prosthesis, the examiner should check "yes" and describe the diminished functioning. The question simply asks whether the functional loss is to the same degree as
- if there were an amputation of the affected limb.
- 10A. Due to the Veterans hip or thigh condition(s), is there functional impairment of an extremity such that no effective functions remain other than that which would be equally well served by an amputation with prosthesis (functions of the lower extremity include balance and propulsion, etc.)?
- Yes, functioning is so diminished that amputation with prosthesis would equally serve the Veteran
- If yes, indicate extremities for which this applies:
- Right lower
- Left lower
- 10B. For each checked extremity, identify the condition causing loss of function, describe loss of effective function and provide specific examples (brief summary):
Section XI Diagnostic Testing Form page 12
Printed at the top of this section (1)
- Note: Testing listed below is not indicated for every condition. The diagnosis of degenerative arthritis (osteoarthritis) or post-traumatic arthritis must be confirmed by imaging studies. Once such arthritis has been documented, even if in the past, no further imaging studies are required by VA, even if arthritis has worsened.
- 11A. Have imaging studies been performed in conjunction with this examination?
- 11B. If yes, is degenerative or post-traumatic arthritis documented?
- Indicate side.
- Right
- Left
- Both
- 11C. If yes provide type of test or procedure, date and results (brief summary):
- 11D. Are there any other significant diagnostic test findings or results related to the claimed condition(s) and/or diagnosis(es), that were reviewed in conjunction with this examination?
- If yes, provide type of test or procedure, date and results (brief summary):
- 11E. If any test results are other than normal, indicate relationship of abnormal findings to diagnosed conditions:
Section XII Functional Impact Form page 13
Printed at the top of this section (1)
- Note: Provide the impact of only the diagnosed condition(s), without consideration of the impact of other medical conditions or factors, such as age.
- 12A. Regardless of the Veteran's current employment status, do the conditions listed in the diagnosis section impact his/her ability to perform any type of occupational task (such as standing, walking, lifting, sitting, etc.)?
- If yes, describe the functional impact of each condition, providing one or more examples:
Section XIII Remarks Form page 13
Only if this applies: There are additional relevant facts, explanations or examination limitations to record.
- 13A. Remarks (if any - please identify the section to which the remark pertains when appropriate).
1 other section of this form covers other conditions, the examiner's signature, or answers you gave above, and is not part of this prep view. The examiner still works from the whole form.
This is a preparation view built from the current public VA forms. It is not an official VA crosswalk, it does not decide which exam VA orders, and it does not tell the examiner to skip anything. Measurements, diagnoses and opinions on the form are the examiner's to record.
What to expect at your C&P exam
A hip exam is a hands-on physical exam. The examiner measures how the hip moves, tests it, and reviews imaging, then rates under 38 CFR 4.71a.
1Initial interview (history)
- When the hip problem started and its cause.
- Pain in the hip, groin, or thigh, and what makes it worse.
- Flare-ups, giving way, surgeries or a hip replacement.
- Whether you use a cane, walker, or brace.
- Effect on walking, sitting, and work.
2Physical examination
- Range of motion measured with a goniometer: bending the hip, straightening it, moving the leg out to the side, and rotation, in degrees.
- The point in the motion where pain begins, and repetitive-use testing.
- Strength testing and checking for ankylosis (a frozen joint) or a flail joint.
- Watching you walk.
3Diagnostic tests the examiner may rely on
Imaging is usually already in your records.
4Functional assessment
- How much the hip motion is limited and whether you need an assistive device, which set the rating.
- Findings map to the tiers in 38 CFR 4.71a (hip and thigh DCs 5250-5255).
Test explainers open MedlinePlus (NIH National Library of Medicine), or Wikipedia where MedlinePlus has no matching page. This describes what happens and what is measured, not how to influence a result.
Rating Levels for DC 5252
The following tiers are reproduced from 38 CFR Part 4, the VA Schedule for Rating Disabilities. Toggle between the official VA criteria and a Plain English explanation.
Plain-English summaries are AI-generated to explain the official criteria. The official 38 CFR language is the binding legal standard. When in doubt, ask a VSO.
Evidence cited in published BVA decisions for DC 5252
Each row counts the issues for this diagnostic code that the Board granted or denied and whose decision text discussed that type of evidence. An issue is one condition the Board ruled on, and one decision can contain several. Remanded issues are not included. This is a count from the public record, not a prediction or a recommendation for any claim.
- Service treatment records: discussed in 1,163 granted or denied BVA issues (240 granted; 923 denied)
- Buddy / lay statements: discussed in 820 granted or denied BVA issues (198 granted; 622 denied)
- Medical literature: discussed in 72 granted or denied BVA issues (32 granted; 40 denied)
What the Board discussed in granted decisions for DC 5252
The themes below were extracted by clustering 500 grant-factor sentences from published Board of Veterans Appeals decisions for this diagnostic code. Frequencies indicate how often each theme appeared in the sample. This is a factual aggregate of the public record, not advice or strategy for any specific claim.
- 34% Benefit of the doubt doctrine cited as inapplicableThe Board noted that because the preponderance of the evidence weighed against the claim, the benefit of the doubt doctrine was not for application and the claim was denied.168 of 500 sample sentences
- 19% Benefit of the doubt statutory standard citedThe Board cited the legal standard requiring VA to give the benefit of the doubt to the claimant when there is an approximate balance of positive and negative evidence regarding any material issue.96 of 500 sample sentences
- 18% Evidence found in equipoise warranting benefit of the doubtThe Board found the evidence for and against the claim to be in approximate balance or relative equipoise and resolved the benefit of the doubt in the Veteran's favor to grant or sustain a rating.88 of 500 sample sentences
- 11% Benefit of the doubt applied to grant specific ratingThe Board affording the Veteran the benefit of the doubt found that the Veteran's disability picture more nearly approximated a specific higher rating criterion, and the rating was granted.55 of 500 sample sentences
- 10% Nexus opinion recorded as at least as likely as notA VA or private examiner opined that the Veteran's current disability was at least as likely as not related to, caused by, or aggravated by an in-service injury, event, disease, or service-connected condition.48 of 500 sample sentences
- 4% Flare-up and functional loss noted in rating analysisThe Board noted that functional impairment during flare-ups, pain on motion, or lack of endurance supported a finding that range of motion was further limited than objectively measured, affecting the applicable rating.18 of 500 sample sentences
- 3% Hip or thigh range of motion findings recordedThe Board recorded specific measured or estimated degrees of flexion, extension, abduction, or adduction of the hip or thigh as the basis for assigning or denying a particular disability rating under the applicable diagnostic code.14 of 500 sample sentences
- 3% Credible lay statements noted in support of ratingThe Board found the Veteran's lay reports of pain, functional limitation, or continuous symptoms to be competent and credible, and accorded them significant probative value in the rating determination.13 of 500 sample sentences
When the Board found the exam inadequate (DC 5252)
In 4,227 published Board of Veterans' Appeals decisions involving this condition, the Board found a C&P examination or medical opinion inadequate. Where the defect could be read from the decision, it was most often one of the following (counts are a floor from the decisions on file, not a total):
- 1,245 Failed to address a contention or part of the condition
- 936 Conclusion given without a supporting rationale
- 738 Veteran's lay statements not considered
- 338 Flare-ups or functional loss not addressed
- 293 Opinion relied on the absence of records instead of the evidence
- 190 Claims file or records not reviewed
- 141 Examiner said an opinion would require speculation
- 57 Exam too old to reflect current severity
- 46 Wrong legal standard or question applied
An inadequate exam is usually sent back for a new one rather than decided against the veteran. This is a factual report of published decisions, not advice about any exam or claim; whether an exam is adequate is decided case by case.
Disclaimer: This page reproduces public Department of Veterans Affairs forms (DBQs) and verbatim text from 38 CFR Part 4 (the VA Schedule for Rating Disabilities). It is informational only and is not legal or medical advice. For guidance on a specific claim, contact a VA-accredited representative.