VA Disability Rating for Cartilage, semilunar, dislocated, with frequent episodes of "locking," pain, and effusion into the joint (DC 5258)

Body system: Musculoskeletal SystemRegulation: 38 CFR § 4.71aDBQ: MUSC Knee and lower leg

This code covers a dislocated meniscus (the rubbery cartilage cushions in your knee) that causes your knee to frequently 'lock up,' creates ongoing pain, and leads to swelling from fluid buildup in the joint. The VA rates this specific combination of symptoms at 20% disability. This rating recognizes that while you can still function, you're dealing with regular knee problems that affect your daily activities and mobility.

Rating levels

  • 20%: You have a piece of cartilage in your knee joint (called semilunar cartilage or meniscus) that has moved out of its normal position and regularly causes your knee to get stuck or lock up so you can't bend or straighten it properly. Along with this locking, you experience ongoing pain and swelling in the joint where fluid builds up (effusion).

Symptoms Recorded in Granted Knee and Lower-leg Conditions DecisionsCollapse

We analyzed 9,798 granted Board decisions involving knee and lower-leg conditions for symptoms named in sentences about the condition (rating-criteria recitations excluded). Descriptive of the published record, what the Board wrote down, not a checklist of what to report.

VA's rule for DC 5258, word for word

Cartilage, semilunar, dislocated, with frequent episodes of “locking,” pain, and effusion into the joint

VA's words that name a symptom charted below. Every level is in Rating Levels above, under the "Official VA criteria" tab.

Bar length shows decisions. Percentages remain context.

Swelling
3,884 decisions39.6% of granted
Instability
3,532 decisions36.0% of granted
Popping or crepitus
1,832 decisions18.7% of granted
Weakness
1,558 decisions15.9% of granted
Locking"locking" in VA's sentence above
1,524 decisions15.6% of granted
Giving way or buckling
1,346 decisions13.7% of granted
Stiffness
1,228 decisions12.5% of granted

A small blue tag means VA's sentence names the same symptom, in the same word or its medical word. The bars count any mention of the symptom, at any severity, even to say it was absent. VA's sentence has its own conditions. A tag does not show that any rating level was met, and a symptom with no tag can still matter.

VA's words are today's rule (38 CFR 4.71a, last amended January 14, 2025). The bars cover decisions from 1992 to 2026, decided under the wording of their time, which may have named different symptoms.

These bars count whole decisions whose overall result was granted. The At the Board box on this page counts each appealed issue.

Detected by phrase-reading the decision text with condition-specific vocabularies. Source: Board of Veterans' Appeals decisions, RateMyVSO analysis.

Disclaimer: This tool is for informational purposes only and is not legal or medical advice. Always consult with your VSO representative or a VA-accredited attorney for guidance on your specific claim.