Original research

Presumptive & Toxic-Exposure Claims at the Board

A presumption lets a veteran skip proving the medical link when service and a qualifying exposure are established. Across the published record, Board grant rates for these pathways range from 45% for PACT Act conditions down to 22.2% for radiation, against a site-wide baseline of 35.5%. When a presumptive claim is denied, one element is missing far more often than the others.

45%PACT Act grant rate
35.5%all claims baseline
50%of denials: no qualifying service or exposure

How this research is built: every Board of Veterans' Appeals decision published by VA is public, and anyone can read one at a time. RateMyVSO downloads and analyzes the complete published record, flagging which claims involve a presumptive exposure pathway, PACT Act, Agent Orange, Camp Lejeune, Gulf War, and tracking their outcomes separately from the rest of the record. The result is one of the largest structured research datasets built from the published Board record. It updates automatically every week as new decisions publish.

Updated November 2026

Grant rates by presumptive pathway

Each bar is the Board grant rate among decided appeals involving that exposure or status. Gold marks the pathways that grant above the 35.5% site-wide baseline:

PACT Act conditions45%
60,490 decided issues, 44.3% of all issues remanded. The 2022 law that added new presumptive conditions for toxic exposure.
Burn pits43.9%
30,138 decided issues, 46.2% of all issues remanded. Airborne hazards from open-air burn pits in Iraq, Afghanistan, and Southwest Asia.
Camp Lejeune water36.4%
30,466 decided issues, 43.8% of all issues remanded. Contaminated drinking water at the base between 1953 and 1987.
Agent Orange & herbicides33.6%
236,113 decided issues, 38.1% of all issues remanded. Vietnam, the Korean DMZ, and other herbicide-exposure claims.
Former prisoners of war28.4%
61,435 decided issues, 17% of all issues remanded. Conditions presumed service connected for former POWs.
Asbestos27.3%
40,003 decided issues, 40.8% of all issues remanded. Insulation, shipyards, and other occupational asbestos exposure.
Gulf War illness26.5%
26,859 decided issues, 51.7% of all issues remanded. Undiagnosed and medically unexplained chronic multisymptom illness.
Ionizing radiation22.2%
25,519 decided issues, 40.7% of all issues remanded. Atmospheric nuclear testing, Hiroshima/Nagasaki occupation, and other exposure.
Important context: these are contested appeals at the Board, not all presumptive claims. A presumption that plainly applies is usually granted by the VA long before a case reaches the Board, so the appeals counted here lean toward harder, disputed cases. Read the rates as the difficulty of the contested tail, not the odds of a straightforward presumptive claim.

Why presumptive claims are denied

To win, even a presumptive claim still needs three things: a current diagnosis, qualifying service or exposure, and a link between them. The presumption is meant to supply that last link automatically. When the Board denied a presumptive claim and the record showed which element fell short, this is what was missing, across 61,798 classified denials:

No qualifying service or exposure50%
30,919 denials, the record did not place the veteran in the covered time, place, or exposure
No current diagnosis27.7%
17,145 denials, no present diagnosis of a condition on the presumptive list
No medical nexus22.2%
13,734 denials, the presumption did not apply and no independent medical link was shown
What this means: The record could not place the veteran in the covered time, place, unit, or exposure the presumption requires. No current diagnosis is the next most common gap, at 27.7%.

These claims are remanded often

Presumptive and toxic-exposure appeals are sent back for more development at a high rate: 36.5% of presumptive-theory issues were remanded rather than decided outright. Exposure questions frequently require the Board to order additional records, a medical opinion, or verification of service before it can decide, which is why so many are returned rather than granted or denied on the spot.

Methodology

This report aggregates published decisions of the Board of Veterans' Appeals at the issue level. A pathway's population is the decided issues on appeals carrying that exposure or status signal (for example Agent Orange, burn pits, PACT Act, Camp Lejeune, radiation, asbestos, or former prisoner of war), so an appeal is counted as involving the exposure, not necessarily decided solely on it. Gulf War illness is counted issue by issue instead: an AI reading of each issue on these appeals found which issues were claimed, considered or decided as a Gulf War illness under 38 CFR 3.317, and only those issues count. An appeal decided after that reading counts every issue, the same way as the other pathways. Grant rate is granted divided by granted-plus-denied; remand rate is remanded of all issues. The denial breakdown uses the element of service connection the Board identified as missing among presumptive-theory denials. Data as of November 2026; figures refresh weekly.

Cite this research

RateMyVSO. (November 2026). Presumptive and Toxic-Exposure Claim Outcomes at the Board of Veterans' Appeals. https://ratemyvso.net/dc/presumptive-outcomes

Free to cite and link with attribution. Figures derived from published Board of Veterans' Appeals decisions.

Educational and encyclopedic only, not legal advice, and not a prediction of any individual claim. Figures describe patterns in published Board decisions. For help with a claim, find a VA-accredited representative.