Original research

The Private-Opinion Edge

A private medical opinion has always helped a service-connection claim at the Board. But across the highest-volume conditions, its edge has nearly doubled in thirty years, from a 20.2-point advantage in the 1990s to 37.5 points today.

+37.5point edge today (2019+)
1.9×the 1990s edge (+20.2)
79.8%granted with a private opinion

How this research is built: every Board of Veterans' Appeals decision published by VA is public, and anyone can read one at a time. RateMyVSO downloads and analyzes the complete published record, identifying who wrote the medical opinion in each decision (private doctor, VA examiner, both, or none) and tracking the grant-rate difference over three decades. The result is one of the largest structured research datasets built from the published Board record. It updates automatically every week as new decisions publish.

Updated November 2026

The gap has widened since 2010

Grouping decisions on the 30 most-appealed conditions by decade, and comparing those where the file held a private medical opinion against those with only a VA opinion or none, both grant rates rose over time, but the ones with a private opinion rose far faster:

DecadeWith private opinionWithoutEdge (points)
1992-1999 39.5% (7,503) 19.3% (48,860) +20.2
2000-2009 40.1% (21,131) 21.5% (94,443) +18.6
2010-2018 64.9% (39,761) 36.8% (155,043) +28.1
2019-2026 79.8% (85,368) 42.3% (256,084) +37.5
1992-1999+20.2 pts
private 39.5% vs no private 19.3%, a gap of 20.2 points
2000-2009+18.6 pts
private 40.1% vs no private 21.5%, a gap of 18.6 points
2010-2018+28.1 pts
private 64.9% vs no private 36.8%, a gap of 28.1 points
2019-2026+37.5 pts
private 79.8% vs no private 42.3%, a gap of 37.5 points
Why this matters: the baseline (no private opinion) climbed from 19.3% to 42.3%, so the Board grants more overall. But files with a private opinion climbed from 39.5% to 79.8%, and the gap between them grew from 20.2 to 37.5 points. The measured advantage in the record has widened as well.
Visual guide: The Private-Opinion Edge Over Time Board grant-rate comparison with and without a detected private medical opinion, current edge 37.5 percentage points, 79.8 percent granted with versus 42.3 percent without. Opens the full-size chart, free to save or print.

The trend holds across conditions

It is not one condition driving the pattern. Here is the grant rate with a private opinion, by decade, for the twelve most-appealed conditions. Each ends higher than it began:

Condition1992-19992000-20092010-20182019-2026
Hearing loss48.6%48.9%71.3%79.2%
Posttraumatic stress disorder41.9%45.7%73.3%85.1%
Tinnitus, recurrent59.3%53.2%79.1%85.1%
Lumbosacral or cervical strain31.4%27.1%43%69.1%
Leg, limitation of flexion of39.8%32.9%49.5%71%
Sleep Apnea Syndromes34.5%46.3%76.9%87.1%
Hypertensive vascular disease28.6%36.5%49.1%74.8%
Diabetes mellitus33.1%29.3%44.7%68.8%
Major depressive disorder37.8%40.6%77.3%86%
Degenerative arthritis, other than post-traumatic36.7%43.4%70.7%79.6%
Paralysis of sciatic nerve33.9%33.1%61.8%76.7%
Migraine37.7%43.5%75.8%88.1%
Visual guide: Private Opinion Outcomes by Condition Board grant-rate comparison by condition with and without a detected private medical opinion, Gastroesophageal reflux disease shows the highest edge at 51.3 percentage points. Opens the full-size chart, free to save or print.

Methodology

This report aggregates published decisions of the Board of Veterans' Appeals at the issue level, limited to service-connection issues on the 30 highest-volume diagnostic codes. A decision is counted as "with a private opinion" when the record identifies a private or non-VA medical opinion on the nexus question, and "without" when the only medical opinion was a VA examiner's or there was none. Grant rate is granted divided by granted-plus-denied. The private/no-private classification comes from the language of each decision. These figures describe the published record; they are not legal advice and do not predict the outcome of any individual claim. Data as of November 2026; figures refresh weekly.

Cite this research

RateMyVSO. (November 2026). The Private-Opinion Edge: How the Value of a Private Nexus Opinion at the Board of Veterans' Appeals Has Widened Over Three Decades. https://ratemyvso.net/dc/nexus-trend-report

Free to cite and link with attribution. Figures derived from published Board of Veterans' Appeals decisions.

Educational and encyclopedic only, not legal advice, and not a prediction of any individual claim. Figures describe patterns in published Board decisions. For help with a claim, find a VA-accredited representative.

Want a nexus letter template to take to your doctor? It is free in Prepare My Claim. Add your condition, then open its nexus letter. You get a structure with a fictional example and fields for your own records, ready to edit and print as a draft. Your doctor reviews your records, decides on the opinion, and signs only their own work.