Original research

The Theory Gap: How Grant Rates Vary by Legal Theory

The legal theory a claim is argued on (direct, secondary, presumptive, or aggravation) tracks with how often the Board of Veterans' Appeals grants it. Across 2,299,396 decided issues in the published record, secondary service connection was granted at 47.7%, above direct service connection at 35.4%.

47.7%secondary connection
35.4%direct connection
42.2%aggravation

How this research is built: every Board of Veterans' Appeals decision published by VA is public, and anyone can read one at a time. RateMyVSO downloads and analyzes the complete published record, classifying the legal theory argued in each claim (direct, secondary, presumptive, or aggravation) and tracking how often each theory is granted. The result is one of the largest structured research datasets built from the published Board record. It updates automatically every week as new decisions publish.

Updated November 2026

Grant rate by way of establishing service connection

There is more than one way to link a condition to service. A claim can be direct (the condition began in service), secondary (it was caused or worsened by an already service-connected condition), presumptive (the law presumes a link, from a qualifying exposure or a chronic disease that appears soon after service), or by aggravation (service made a pre-existing condition worse). Here is how often the Board granted each, among issues it decided on the merits:

Direct service connection35.4%
1,016,482 decided issues, granted or denied
Secondary service connection47.7%
169,516 decided issues, granted or denied
Presumptive service connection39.2%
108,898 decided issues, granted or denied
Aggravation of a condition42.2%
23,598 decided issues, granted or denied
Reading this: secondary connection was granted about 12.3 points more often than direct in the decided record. Secondary service connection has the highest grant rate; aggravation of a condition is the smallest group by far. These describe patterns in published Board decisions; they are not a prediction about any individual claim, and the right theory for a claim depends entirely on its facts.

Aggravation is two different laws

The combined aggravation figure above covers two claims that the law treats differently. Under 38 CFR 3.306 a condition that already existed before service was made worse by service itself; there is no second condition involved. Under 38 CFR 3.310(b) one condition was made worse by another service-connected condition, which is a secondary relationship and pays only the increment above a measured baseline. Splitting the 24,767 aggravation issues in the record:

RouteIssuesDecidedGrant rate
Aggravation by service (38 CFR 3.306)11,96111,67428.3%
Aggravation route unresolved9,0958,72847.9%
Aggravation by another condition (38 CFR 3.310(b))3,7113,19377.4%
Reading this: the three rows add back to the 24,767 issues in the combined aggravation row above. Aggravation route unresolved is a real answer, not a gap being hidden: those decisions record a worsening without stating clearly enough which law it ran under, and nothing is guessed into a legal route to make the split look tidier. Route classification is a manual layer and does not refresh with the weekly figures.

Conditions most often granted on a secondary theory

Among claims argued as secondary service connection, these fifteen conditions had the highest Board grant rate (of at least 500 decided issues each). Several are classic downstream conditions, sleep apnea, migraines, and depression tied to another service-connected disability:

Other claim types, for context

These answer a different question: not how to connect a condition to service, but a rating increase, unemployability, an earlier effective date, or correcting a past error. They sit on their own axis and are shown here only for context:

Increased rating30.1%
727,295 decided issues
Earlier effective date35.1%
157,927 decided issues
Unemployability (TDIU)56.2%
82,008 decided issues
Clear and unmistakable error24.4%
14,957 decided issues
These appeals reach the Board after the underlying conditions are already service connected and rated, so do not read them against the theories above as if they were the same choice.

Methodology

This report aggregates published decisions of the Board of Veterans' Appeals at the issue level. Each decided issue carries the legal theory the Board addressed (direct, secondary, presumptive, aggravation, increased rating, unemployability, effective date, or clear and unmistakable error); an issue the Board decided under two theories counts under each, so the theory rows add up to more than the total. Grant rate is granted divided by granted-plus-denied; remanded and dismissed issues are excluded from the rate. The secondary-conditions table is limited to codes with at least 500 decided secondary issues. Data as of November 2026; the underlying figures refresh weekly.

Cite this research

RateMyVSO. (November 2026). The Theory Gap: Grant Rates by Legal Theory Across 2,299,396 Board of Veterans' Appeals Issues. https://ratemyvso.net/dc/theory-report

Free to cite and link with attribution. Figures derived from published Board of Veterans' Appeals decisions.

Educational and encyclopedic only, not legal advice, and not a prediction of any individual claim. Figures describe patterns in published Board decisions. For help with a claim, find a VA-accredited representative.