Musculoskeletal Conditions Rating Guide

Joint, spine, and bone conditions are the most common category of VA disability claims (VBA Annual Benefits Report, most prevalent body system), and every one of them is rated under the same schedule: 38 CFR 4.71a. A knee, a lower back, a shoulder, and an ankle are scored by the same handful of rules. Learn those rules once and you understand your whole claim. This guide explains the rules that decide every musculoskeletal rating, then points you to the detailed guide for your specific condition.

One-page guide: Musculoskeletal Conditions Rating Guide in One Page Musculoskeletal system overview covering diagnosis and code selection, functional loss, service-connection paths, symptoms, record building, claim gaps, and medical relationships to evaluate. Opens the full-size chart, free to save or print.

The rules that decide every musculoskeletal claim

Most joint and spine codes are rated on limitation of motion: the examiner measures how far the joint bends and straightens with a goniometer, then compares it to the normal range in 38 CFR 4.71 (Plate I and II). Less motion means a higher rating. But a string of rules sitting on top of that measurement decide far more claims than the raw degrees do.

1. Painful motion earns the minimum (38 CFR 4.59)

A joint that hurts when it moves is entitled to at least the minimum compensable rating for the joint (usually 10 percent) even if the range of motion is close to normal, where the joint's code provides a compensable level. Pain that limits function is a disability in itself. If the exam records painful motion and the rating still came back at 0 percent, look closer at the exam.

2. Functional loss and flare-ups (38 CFR 4.40 and 4.45, the DeLuca rules)

The rating is not just your range of motion on a calm day in the exam room. Under DeLuca v. Brown and Mitchell v. Shinseki, the VA must account for additional loss from pain, weakness, fatigability, and incoordination, including during flare-ups and after repeated use. The examiner is supposed to measure your motion again after repetitions and estimate how much more you lose during a flare.

3. The exam must test all four ways (Correia v. McDonald)

Since Correia v. McDonald (2016), a joint exam must record range of motion in active and passive motion, and in weight-bearing and non-weight-bearing, and test the opposite undamaged joint for comparison where relevant. An exam that skips these is legally inadequate and is grounds to ask for a new one. Under Sharp v. Shulkin, if the exam was not during a flare, the examiner must still estimate the extra loss a flare causes or explain why they cannot.

4. Ankylosis is rated higher than stiffness

Ankylosis is a joint frozen in one position, from disease, injury, or surgical fusion. Because a fused joint has no usable motion, it is rated higher than mere limitation of motion, and an unfavorable position (fixed at a bad angle) rates higher than a favorable one.

5. The bilateral factor (38 CFR 4.26)

When you have compensable disabilities of both arms, both legs, or paired skeletal muscles, for example a right knee and a left knee, the VA adds an extra 10 percent of the combined value of those bilateral disabilities before combining with the rest. It is easy to miss, and it quietly raises many two-sided claims.

6. Instability and limited motion can stack (no pyramiding)

The anti-pyramiding rule (38 CFR 4.14) says you cannot rate the same symptom twice. But distinct manifestations of one joint can carry separate ratings. Under VA General Counsel opinions, a knee with both instability (DC 5257) and limitation of motion or arthritis (DC 5003, 5260, 5261) can carry a rating for each when the record shows both problems, because giving way and losing bend are different manifestations. The separate ratings are not automatic; they depend on distinct findings that do not overlap.

7. The amputation rule is a ceiling (38 CFR 4.68)

The combined rating for one limb cannot exceed what an amputation at the elective level of that limb would pay. It is a cap, not a floor, and it rarely bites unless a single extremity carries several high ratings.

Arthritis has two distinct fallback paths, and they do not mix. Degenerative arthritis (DC 5003) is rated on the limitation of motion of the affected joint. If motion is limited but the limitation is noncompensable under the joint's own code, X-ray-confirmed arthritis with the required findings can support 10 percent for each affected major joint or minor-joint group. Only in the absence of limitation of motion does the separate X-ray-only path apply: 10 percent for X-ray involvement of 2 or more major joints or minor-joint groups, or 20 percent with occasional incapacitating exacerbations. Those X-ray-only ratings are never combined with a limitation-of-motion rating. See the arthritis guide.

Choose the musculoskeletal rating lane and measure function

Musculoskeletal claims run in several distinct lanes, and the lane decides which measurements matter. Identify it first, then measure function inside it.

Rating laneWhat controlsRecords that show it
Joint motionWhat controlsMeasured motion, painful motion, repeated use, flare loss, and ankylosis when presentRecords that show itGoniometer findings, active and passive testing, weight-bearing and non-weight-bearing testing where possible, flare estimate, treatment notes
Instability or joint structureWhat controlsThe distinct instability, meniscus, dislocation, or other code-specific findingRecords that show itStability testing, imaging when relevant, braces, falls or giving-way history, operative reports
SpineWhat controlsThoracolumbar or cervical motion, ankylosis, qualifying incapacitating episodes when the intervertebral disc formula applies, and distinct neurologic residualsRecords that show itSpine examination, treatment and imaging, prescribed bed-rest record when applicable, nerve findings, bowel or bladder findings
Muscle injuryWhat controlsMuscle group, wound or injury history, cardinal signs and symptoms, strength, endurance, scarring, tissue loss, and functional impairmentRecords that show itService and operative records, examination of the muscle group, strength and endurance testing, scar findings
Prosthetic replacement or resurfacingWhat controlsThe exact joint code, surgery date, code-specific temporary period, and later chronic residualsRecords that show itOperative report, hospital discharge, post-operative examinations, pain, weakness, motion, and functional findings
Scar or amputation residualWhat controlsScar criteria, painful or unstable scar, loss of part, loss of use, and the amputation ruleRecords that show itScar examination, measurements, pain or instability, prosthetic or assistive-device records, functional examination

The rating rules above only work if the record captures function, not just degrees. Sections 4.40 and 4.45 require evaluating normal working movement, strength, speed, coordination, and endurance, along with weakness, fatigability, incoordination, pain, swelling, instability, and interference with sitting, standing, and weight-bearing. Section 4.59 calls for pain testing on active and passive motion, and in weight-bearing and non-weight-bearing, where possible. Under Sharp v. Shulkin, the examiner must elicit enough information about your flares to estimate the functional loss they cause when feasible; the absence of a flare on exam day is not by itself a complete explanation. Six records make that estimate possible:

RecordWhat makes it usable
Baseline motionWhere pain begins, not only the farthest point reached
Repeated useWhat changes after repetitions or sustained activity
Flare frequencyHow often, how long, and what triggers the flare
Flare functionThe specific movement or task lost, such as standing, lifting, gripping, reaching, or walking
Weakness and stabilityGiving way, reduced strength, poor coordination, swelling, or atrophy when present
Assistive devicesBrace, cane, crutches, or other device, including how often it is used and why

A complete joint report records baseline motion, where pain begins, repeated-use findings, the frequency and duration of flares, and a medically supportable estimate of additional functional loss when feasible. If an estimate cannot be given, the report should explain why the available facts do not permit one.

The joint-specific guides show how these records meet each code: joint motion, arthritis, sciatica and radiculopathy, knee, and lumbar spine.

Build the timeline that connects the current disability to service

A musculoskeletal claim may begin with one documented injury, but many conditions develop through repeated lifting, running, vibration, load carriage, awkward positions, or cumulative wear. The evidence question is still the same: what happened in service, what disability exists now, and what competent evidence connects the two.

Timeline elementExamples of useful records
In-service event or duty patternExamples of useful recordsTreatment record, line-of-duty record, accident report, deployment record, military occupational specialty or duty description, training and equipment history
Symptoms during or after serviceExamples of useful recordsContemporaneous complaints, physical profiles, competent lay observations, dated personal history
Current diagnosis and exact body partExamples of useful recordsImaging, orthopedic or rehabilitation assessment, operative history, examination
Continuity and other injuriesExamples of useful recordsTreatment timeline, work and recreation history, later accidents or intercurrent injuries addressed honestly
Medical connectionExamples of useful recordsA reasoned medical explanation that accounts for the in-service history, current diagnosis, time course, and other plausible causes
A duty title alone does not medically prove causation. A missing service treatment entry does not automatically end the inquiry either. The complete record matters, including competent lay evidence and the medical explanation of the timeline.

A surgery can change the rating path more than once

Joint surgery does not produce one permanent rating. It moves the claim through separate states, and the record for each one is different.

  • Convalescence: a temporary total rating may apply when the regulatory surgery, immobilization, or severe post-operative residual criteria are met (see 38 CFR 4.30).
  • Code-specific prosthetic period: some joint-replacement codes provide a separate total-rating period after the initial convalescent month. The exact duration depends on the joint and the procedure, so the current diagnostic code controls.
  • Chronic residuals: after the temporary period, VA evaluates the remaining pain, weakness, motion loss, instability, or other code-specific residuals.

The operative report, the discharge date, and the post-operative examinations are what move a claim between these states, so the dates matter as much as the diagnosis.

Find the guide for your condition

The rules above apply across the board. For the exact rating table, the C&P exam, and the Board data for your specific joint, open the dedicated guide:

AreaGuideDC codes
KneeKnee Claims Guide5055, 5256-5263
Lower backLumbar Spine Guide5235-5243
NeckCervical Spine Guide5237, 5241, 5242
Shoulder, elbow, wrist, hip, ankleJoint Motion Guide5200-5274
Flatfoot (pes planus)Flatfoot Guide5276
Bunion, hammertoe, foot injuriesFoot Conditions Guide5279-5284
Arthritis (degenerative, traumatic)Arthritis Guide5003, 5010
Widespread pain (fibromyalgia)Fibromyalgia Guide5025
Radiating nerve pain (sciatica)Sciatica & Radiculopathy Guide8520

Radiating pain down a leg or arm is rated under the neurological schedule, not 4.71a, but it is so often paired with a back or neck claim that it belongs on this map. For any code not listed, open its condition lookup page for the rating levels and Board data.

Common secondary conditions

Musculoskeletal injuries rarely stay in one place. Because the body compensates for a bad joint, one service-connected condition often opens the door to several secondary claims:

  • The opposite joint. Favoring an injured knee, hip, or ankle overloads the other side. A service-connected right knee that causes a left-knee condition is a classic secondary claim.
  • Up and down the chain. An altered gait travels: a bad ankle strains the knee, a bad knee strains the hip and back, and a fused or painful joint changes how you walk.
  • Radiculopathy from the spine. A back or neck disability that pinches a nerve root produces radiating leg or arm pain, rated separately under the nerve codes. See the sciatica guide.
  • Mental health from chronic pain. Long-term pain and lost mobility drive depression and anxiety, which can be claimed as secondary to the physical condition. See secondary conditions.

Each dedicated guide above shows the live Board grant rates for that joint's most common secondary pairings.

Records that show what the schedule measures

The official joint and muscle examination forms ask for a specific set of fields. A complete record covers the same ground:

  • Exact joint or muscle group: the specific body part, and the side plus dominant hand where the code distinguishes them.
  • Motion and pain: range of motion in degrees taken with a goniometer, active and passive, weight-bearing and non-weight-bearing where possible, and the point where pain begins.
  • Repeated use and flares: what changes after repetitions or sustained activity, how often flares occur, how long they last, and a medically supportable estimate of the additional loss when feasible.
  • Strength and stability: muscle strength, endurance, giving way, stability testing, atrophy, and swelling when present.
  • Neurologic residuals: numbness, radiating pain, reflex or sensation changes, and any bowel or bladder findings tied to a spine condition.
  • Devices, surgery, and scars: braces, canes, or other assistive devices, operative reports and dates, prosthetic implants, and any painful or unstable scar.
  • Ordinary functional effects: standing, walking, lifting, gripping, reaching, climbing, sleeping, and work or household limits.

The matching DBQ prompts an examiner to record most of these fields in the schedule's own terms.

Evidence Cited in Published Back and Neck (Spine) Decisions

We analyzed 305,759 published Board decisions involving back and neck (spine) for condition-specific evidence, counting only case-specific mentions (boilerplate recitations excluded). "Favorable" is the share of decisions citing that evidence where every issue was granted or the outcome was mixed; the baseline across all these decisions is 43.4%, combining every diagnostic code below. A decision that rules on more than one of the codes below is counted once here, so the per-code counts can add up to more. Evidence appearing in a decision does not mean it decided the case. Descriptive of the published record, not a prediction.

Bar length shows decisions citing the evidence.

In-service back or neck injury documented
71,233 decisions52.2% favorable
Range of motion measured in degrees
67,998 decisions67.1% favorable
Flare-ups and additional functional loss addressed
62,254 decisions58.3% favorable
Radiculopathy or EMG/nerve-conduction findings
54,563 decisions62.4% favorable
MRI or imaging of the spine
37,818 decisions55.0% favorable
Physician-prescribed bed rest (incapacitating episodes)
29,301 decisions64.8% favorable

By diagnostic code

These codes are grouped together above. They do not perform the same, so find your own code here rather than reading the combined figure. A code retired in the schedule rewrites appears without a link, because its decisions were judged under criteria that no longer apply.

Bar length shows published decisions reviewed.

DC 5237 Lumbosacral or cervical strain
213,809 decisions10,616 granted · 41.1% favorable
DC 5242 Degenerative arthritis, degenerative disc disease other than intervertebral disc syndrome (also, see either DC 5003 or 5010)
61,575 decisions5,561 granted · 51.0% favorable
DC 5243 Intervertebral disc syndrome
38,908 decisions3,585 granted · 51.2% favorable
DC 5235 Vertebral fracture or dislocation
5,649 decisions398 granted · 40.4% favorable
DC 5238 Spinal stenosis
5,287 decisions655 granted · 52.3% favorable

Evidence Cited in Published Knee and Lower-leg Conditions Decisions

We analyzed 191,391 published Board decisions involving knee and lower-leg conditions for condition-specific evidence, counting only case-specific mentions (boilerplate recitations excluded). "Favorable" is the share of decisions citing that evidence where every issue was granted or the outcome was mixed; the baseline across all these decisions is 45.6%, combining every diagnostic code below. A decision that rules on more than one of the codes below is counted once here, so the per-code counts can add up to more. Evidence appearing in a decision does not mean it decided the case. Descriptive of the published record, not a prediction.

Bar length shows decisions citing the evidence.

Range of motion measured in degrees
50,319 decisions67.6% favorable
Meniscal pathology documented
45,357 decisions57.6% favorable
Knee MRI or X-ray findings
38,313 decisions55.5% favorable
Instability testing (Lachman, drawer, McMurray)
31,008 decisions62.0% favorable
Giving way, buckling, or locking reported
29,459 decisions63.1% favorable
Knee replacement (arthroplasty) documented
19,550 decisions55.2% favorable

By diagnostic code

These codes are grouped together above. They do not perform the same, so find your own code here rather than reading the combined figure. A code retired in the schedule rewrites appears without a link, because its decisions were judged under criteria that no longer apply.

Bar length shows published decisions reviewed.

DC 5260 Leg, limitation of flexion of
138,488 decisions5,805 granted · 44.5% favorable
DC 5257 Knee, other impairment of
33,960 decisions1,920 granted · 57.3% favorable
DC 5262 Tibia and fibula, impairment of
14,053 decisions569 granted · 49.0% favorable
DC 5055 Knee, resurfacing or replacement (prosthesis)
13,092 decisions1,166 granted · 50.8% favorable
DC 5259 Cartilage, semilunar, removal of, symptomatic
8,032 decisions432 granted · 50.2% favorable
DC 5261 Leg, limitation of extension of
6,861 decisions243 granted · 68.3% favorable
DC 5258 Cartilage, semilunar, dislocated, with frequent episodes of "locking," pain, and effusion into the joint
6,742 decisions487 granted · 66.9% favorable
DC 5256 Knee, ankylosis of
495 decisions28 granted · 41.8% favorable

Evidence Cited in Published Arthritis Decisions

We analyzed 108,889 published Board decisions involving arthritis for condition-specific evidence, counting only case-specific mentions (boilerplate recitations excluded). "Favorable" is the share of decisions citing that evidence where every issue was granted or the outcome was mixed; the baseline across all these decisions is 49%, combining every diagnostic code below. A decision that rules on more than one of the codes below is counted once here, so the per-code counts can add up to more. Evidence appearing in a decision does not mean it decided the case. Descriptive of the published record, not a prediction.

Bar length shows decisions citing the evidence.

X-ray confirmation of arthritis
33,089 decisions62.4% favorable
Range of motion measured in degrees
30,026 decisions67.7% favorable
Objective painful motion findings
26,322 decisions66.0% favorable
Flare-ups and additional functional loss addressed
25,236 decisions59.5% favorable
Repetitive-use testing performed
11,490 decisions72.8% favorable

By diagnostic code

These codes are grouped together above. They do not perform the same, so find your own code here rather than reading the combined figure. A code retired in the schedule rewrites appears without a link, because its decisions were judged under criteria that no longer apply.

Bar length shows published decisions reviewed.

DC 5003 Degenerative arthritis, other than post-traumatic
86,133 decisions6,274 granted · 51.4% favorable
DC 5010 Post-traumatic arthritis
12,146 decisions743 granted · 42.8% favorable
DC 5002 Multi-joint arthritis (except post-traumatic and gout), 2 or more joints, as an active process
7,914 decisions349 granted · 36.9% favorable
DC 5021 Myositis
6,080 decisions246 granted · 46.0% favorable

Evidence Cited in Published Shoulder and Arm Conditions Decisions

We analyzed 68,455 published Board decisions involving shoulder and arm conditions for condition-specific evidence, counting only case-specific mentions (boilerplate recitations excluded). "Favorable" is the share of decisions citing that evidence where every issue was granted or the outcome was mixed; the baseline across all these decisions is 47.7%, combining every diagnostic code below. A decision that rules on more than one of the codes below is counted once here, so the per-code counts can add up to more. Evidence appearing in a decision does not mean it decided the case. Descriptive of the published record, not a prediction.

Bar length shows decisions citing the evidence.

Rotator cuff pathology (tear, impingement)
21,018 decisions57.6% favorable
Range of motion measured in degrees
15,813 decisions68.5% favorable
Dislocation or instability documented
12,344 decisions55.5% favorable
Shoulder MRI or X-ray findings
11,569 decisions55.1% favorable
Dominant (major) extremity addressed
9,216 decisions66.8% favorable
Motion limited to shoulder level or below
7,537 decisions66.8% favorable

By diagnostic code

These codes are grouped together above. They do not perform the same, so find your own code here rather than reading the combined figure. A code retired in the schedule rewrites appears without a link, because its decisions were judged under criteria that no longer apply.

Bar length shows published decisions reviewed.

DC 5201 Arm, limitation of motion of
61,249 decisions2,757 granted · 48.7% favorable
DC 5203 Clavicle or scapula, impairment of
3,921 decisions203 granted · 43.9% favorable
DC 5202 Humerus, other impairment of
3,514 decisions168 granted · 39.1% favorable
DC 5303 Group III. Function: Elevation and abduction of arm to level of shoulder; act with 1 and 2 of Group II in forward and backward swing of arm. Intrinsic muscles of shoulder girdle: (1) Pectoralis major I (clavicular); (2) deltoid
695 decisions35 granted · 44.6% favorable
DC 5200 Scapulohumeral articulation, ankylosis of
415 decisions28 granted · 65.3% favorable

Evidence Cited in Published Ankle Conditions Decisions

We analyzed 54,347 published Board decisions involving ankle conditions for condition-specific evidence, counting only case-specific mentions (boilerplate recitations excluded). "Favorable" is the share of decisions citing that evidence where every issue was granted or the outcome was mixed; the baseline across all these decisions is 49.7%. Evidence appearing in a decision does not mean it decided the case. Descriptive of the published record, not a prediction.

Bar length shows decisions citing the evidence.

Dorsiflexion / plantar flexion measured in degrees
11,604 decisions68.1% favorable
In-service ankle sprain or fracture documented
10,643 decisions57.4% favorable
Ankle X-ray or MRI findings
9,927 decisions55.4% favorable
Instability, giving way, or brace use
9,838 decisions64.6% favorable
Marked or moderate limitation characterized
7,721 decisions70.8% favorable

Evidence Cited in Published Hip and Thigh Conditions Decisions

We analyzed 43,358 published Board decisions involving hip and thigh conditions for condition-specific evidence, counting only case-specific mentions (boilerplate recitations excluded). "Favorable" is the share of decisions citing that evidence where every issue was granted or the outcome was mixed; the baseline across all these decisions is 47.9%, combining every diagnostic code below. A decision that rules on more than one of the codes below is counted once here, so the per-code counts can add up to more. Evidence appearing in a decision does not mean it decided the case. Descriptive of the published record, not a prediction.

Bar length shows decisions citing the evidence.

Flare-ups and additional functional loss addressed
8,436 decisions68.7% favorable
Hip range of motion measured in degrees
8,295 decisions73.8% favorable
Hip X-ray or MRI findings
6,270 decisions52.4% favorable
Antalgic gait or limp documented
5,233 decisions61.6% favorable
Hip replacement (arthroplasty) documented
5,025 decisions49.0% favorable

By diagnostic code

These codes are grouped together above. They do not perform the same, so find your own code here rather than reading the combined figure. A code retired in the schedule rewrites appears without a link, because its decisions were judged under criteria that no longer apply.

Bar length shows published decisions reviewed.

DC 5252 Thigh, limitation of flexion of
38,124 decisions1,428 granted · 48.6% favorable
DC 5253 Thigh, impairment of
4,424 decisions153 granted · 55.6% favorable
DC 5054 Hip, resurfacing or replacement (prosthesis)
3,616 decisions358 granted · 45.4% favorable

Detected by phrase-reading the decision text with condition-specific vocabularies. Source: Board of Veterans' Appeals decisions, RateMyVSO analysis.

Symptoms Recorded in Granted Back and Neck (Spine) Decisions

We analyzed 19,597 granted Board decisions involving back and neck (spine) for symptoms named in sentences about the condition (rating-criteria recitations excluded). Descriptive of the published record, what the Board wrote down, not a checklist of what to report.

Bar length shows decisions. Percentages remain context.

Chronic or constant pain
6,562 decisions33.5% of granted
Muscle spasm
4,126 decisions21.1% of granted
Radiating pain
2,664 decisions13.6% of granted
Numbness
1,836 decisions9.4% of granted
Weakness
1,507 decisions7.7% of granted
Stiffness
1,256 decisions6.4% of granted

Symptoms Recorded in Granted Knee and Lower-leg Conditions Decisions

We analyzed 9,798 granted Board decisions involving knee and lower-leg conditions for symptoms named in sentences about the condition (rating-criteria recitations excluded). Descriptive of the published record, what the Board wrote down, not a checklist of what to report.

Bar length shows decisions. Percentages remain context.

Swelling
3,884 decisions39.6% of granted
Instability
3,532 decisions36.0% of granted
Popping or crepitus
1,832 decisions18.7% of granted
Weakness
1,558 decisions15.9% of granted
Locking
1,524 decisions15.6% of granted
Giving way or buckling
1,346 decisions13.7% of granted
Stiffness
1,228 decisions12.5% of granted

Symptoms Recorded in Granted Arthritis Decisions

We analyzed 7,530 granted Board decisions involving arthritis for symptoms named in sentences about the condition (rating-criteria recitations excluded). Descriptive of the published record, what the Board wrote down, not a checklist of what to report.

Bar length shows decisions. Percentages remain context.

Instability
534 decisions7.1% of granted
Swelling
382 decisions5.1% of granted
Stiffness
169 decisions2.2% of granted
Tenderness
141 decisions1.9% of granted
Flare-ups
112 decisions1.5% of granted
Grinding or popping (crepitus)
107 decisions1.4% of granted
Muscle spasm
79 decisions1.0% of granted

Symptoms Recorded in Granted Shoulder and Arm Conditions Decisions

We analyzed 3,161 granted Board decisions involving shoulder and arm conditions for symptoms named in sentences about the condition (rating-criteria recitations excluded). Descriptive of the published record, what the Board wrote down, not a checklist of what to report.

Bar length shows decisions. Percentages remain context.

Shoulder pain
2,559 decisions81.0% of granted
Instability or dislocation
995 decisions31.5% of granted
Weakness
605 decisions19.1% of granted
Tenderness
558 decisions17.7% of granted
Flare-ups
399 decisions12.6% of granted
Grinding or popping (crepitus)
345 decisions10.9% of granted
Stiffness
311 decisions9.8% of granted
Swelling
268 decisions8.5% of granted
Numbness
250 decisions7.9% of granted

Symptoms Recorded in Granted Ankle Conditions Decisions

We analyzed 2,580 granted Board decisions involving ankle conditions for symptoms named in sentences about the condition (rating-criteria recitations excluded). Descriptive of the published record, what the Board wrote down, not a checklist of what to report.

Bar length shows decisions. Percentages remain context.

Ankle pain
2,120 decisions82.2% of granted
Swelling
937 decisions36.3% of granted
Instability or giving way
902 decisions35.0% of granted
Weakness
476 decisions18.4% of granted
Stiffness
360 decisions14.0% of granted

Symptoms Recorded in Granted Hip and Thigh Conditions Decisions

We analyzed 1,870 granted Board decisions involving hip and thigh conditions for symptoms named in sentences about the condition (rating-criteria recitations excluded). Descriptive of the published record, what the Board wrote down, not a checklist of what to report.

Bar length shows decisions. Percentages remain context.

Hip pain
1,500 decisions80.2% of granted
Limp or gait disturbance
500 decisions26.7% of granted
Weakness
214 decisions11.4% of granted
Flare-ups
138 decisions7.4% of granted
Stiffness
115 decisions6.1% of granted
Trouble crossing legs
46 decisions2.5% of granted
Fatigability
41 decisions2.2% of granted

Detected by phrase-reading the decision text with condition-specific vocabularies. Source: Board of Veterans' Appeals decisions, RateMyVSO analysis.

Common mistakes

  • Accepting a 0 percent for a painful joint without checking. Painful motion generally supports at least the joint's minimum compensable rating under 4.59. A 0 percent on a joint the exam recorded as painful is a reason to compare the decision and examination with the applicable criteria.
  • Not noticing what the examination left out. When a report does not record active and passive motion, weight-bearing and non-weight-bearing testing, or an estimate of flare-up loss, the file is missing measurements the criteria use. That gap matters.
  • Not checking for distinct knee manifestations. Instability and limitation of motion are distinct manifestations that can carry separate ratings on the same knee when the record shows both. An exam that documents both problems and a decision that rates only one do not match.
  • Forgetting the bilateral factor. Two-sided claims (both knees, both shoulders) get an extra 10 percent under 4.26 that is easy to overlook.
  • Only claiming the first joint. The gait chain and the opposite joint can be secondary claims when a competent medical link is established. Stopping at the original injury leaves those conditions unevaluated.
  • Treating a surgery as one permanent rating. A convalescent period, a code-specific prosthetic period, and the later chronic residuals are separate states with separate records, so the operative and discharge dates matter.

Frequently asked questions

How does the VA rate joint and spine conditions?
Almost all of them are rated under 38 CFR 4.71a on limitation of motion, how far the joint bends and straightens compared to normal. On top of that, painful motion earns at least the minimum rating (4.59), functional loss from flare-ups and repeated use must be counted (the DeLuca rules), ankylosis rates higher than stiffness, and the exam must test motion in several ways (Correia).
Does every painful joint receive a separate rating?
No. Painful motion of a joint generally supports at least the minimum compensable rating where the applicable code provides one, based on objective findings (see 38 CFR 4.59). That is different from stacking codes. Separate evaluations require distinct, non-overlapping manifestations: a knee with documented instability and a knee with limited or painful motion are distinct, so both can be evaluated, while the same pain and the same lost motion cannot be counted twice under different labels (see 38 CFR 4.14). The separate ratings depend on what the record documents; they are not automatic.
Why did I get 0 percent when my joint clearly hurts?
If the exam recorded painful motion, look closer. Under 38 CFR 4.59, actually painful motion of a joint generally warrants at least the joint's minimum compensable rating, usually 10 percent, where the code provides one. A 0 percent in that situation deserves a closer look at the exam.
What is the bilateral factor?
Under 38 CFR 4.26, when you have compensable disabilities of both arms, both legs, or paired muscles, the VA adds an extra 10 percent of the combined value of those bilateral disabilities before combining with your other ratings. It raises many two-sided claims and is often overlooked.
Does a normal exam day erase flare-up loss?
No. A joint examination should use the available history and medical judgment to address the additional functional loss during flares when that is feasible, and explain why not when it is not (Sharp v. Shulkin). A joint examination should also measure active and passive motion and weight-bearing and non-weight-bearing motion where possible (Correia v. McDonald). If a report does not record those measurements, the file is missing facts the criteria use.
What changes after joint replacement?
The rating path moves through separate states rather than settling once. A temporary total rating may apply for convalescence when the regulatory criteria are met (see 38 CFR 4.30), some joint-replacement codes then provide their own total-rating period whose length depends on the joint and procedure, and after that VA evaluates the remaining pain, weakness, motion loss, or instability as chronic residuals. The operative report and the discharge date decide when each state begins, so those dates belong in the file.

Related Tools and Guides

Sources: 38 CFR 4.71a, musculoskeletal ratings · 4.59, painful motion · 4.40 and 4.45, functional loss · 4.26, bilateral factor. Educational only, not legal advice, and not a prediction of any individual claim. Rating criteria and case law change; confirm current details in 38 CFR Part 4. For help with your claim, find a VA-accredited representative.